The report warned that states should “stop providing foolish

The End of EZ Money in California

canada goose outlet london One of the Governor’s more controversial proposals was to reform canada goose coats on sale California’s Enterprise Zones (EZs) program, which was created in 1986 to stimulate economic activity and create jobs for the economically disadvantaged. Budget wonks canada goose store call such credits “tax expenditures,” because the state has to forgo revenue to pay for them. The California Franchise Tax Board has estimated the EZ program cost California $333 million in lost tax revenues in 2005. $197 million of that total was from hiring and sales or use tax canada goose uk outlet credits claimed on corporate tax returns. canada goose outlet london

canada goose outlet jackets The Governor’s latest budget canada goose clearance sale criticizes the Canada Goose online EZs for “significant failings.” Brown says the EZ program encourages the hiring of employees but “it does not encourage the creation of new jobs.” The Governor also slams the program for rewarding employers “even when it is demonstrable that the existence of the (hiring) credit had nothing to do with the fact that they hired a new employee.” canada goose outlet jackets

canada goose outlet in chicago Governor Brown initially proposed last winter a wholesale repeal of the EZ program, but his kinder May proposal made tax credits available only to firms that actually increased their level of employment, and eliminated the practice of retroactive granting of hiring credits for workers who were hired years ago. canada goose outlet in chicago

canada goose outlet store uk The Governor’s decision to cut a break for the EZs was credited to a political calculus designed to entice Canada Goose Outlet a handful of Republican lawmakers to support an extension of the state’s vehicle license fees and sales taxes. But the Republicans would have nothing of cheap canada goose uk it. “The governor certainly wants to find Republican votes, but he’s going to have to do Canada Goose Outlet more than what’s come out of the May revisions,” said Assemblyman Cameron Smyth (R Santa Clarita). “Enterprise zones should be left alone.” Santa Clarita is home to one of the state’s 42 Enterprise Zones. In Kings County, California, an economic development specialist gave this blunt response to Brown’s reform plan: “If you eliminate the goose that lays the golden egg, you’ve killed the economy.” canada goose outlet store uk

canada goose outlet miami But are Enterprise Zones killing the goose? The Enterprise Zone’s performance has drawn its share of critics beyond Governor Brown. A 2009 report from the Public Policy Institute of California suggests that “after more than 20 years, the Canada Goose Coats On Sale program’s effects are still unclear. Our main finding is that, on average, enterprise zones have no effect on business creation or job growth.” The PPIC report infuriated EZ supporters when it concluded, “For a cash strapped state, it is too costly a program to simply continue with ‘business as usual’ without clearer evidence of canada goose uk black friday the program’s benefits or a well defined plan to make the program more effective.” canada goose outlet miami

goose outlet canada One of the companies that has become a familiar face inside California Enterprise Zones is Wal Mart. employees including 70,115 in California. At least three huge distribution centers have been approved by local officials inside canada goose Enterprise Zones, but two of them Barstow and Merced have been held up for years by opposition from local citizens’ groups. goose outlet canada

canada goose outlet factory A Sprawl Busters phone survey this week Canada Goose Parka with 14 EZ managers in California turned up at least 19 Wal Marts built inside the Enterprise Zones in places like Antelope Valley, Imperial Valley, Kings County, Long Beach, Oakland, Richmond, Salinas Valley, Santa Clarita, Shasta, West Sacramento and Yuba. The voucher manager in the city of Palmdale told me that there are 5 Wal Mart’s inside the Antelope Valley Enterprise Zone alone. canada goose outlet factory

canada goose discount uk The exact value canada goose black friday sale of the “hiring tax credits” Wal Mart has received from California is “highly confidential” one EZ manager told me. A spokesman for the California Department of canada goose coats Housing and Community Development, which oversees the EZ program, was unable to disclose the total number of Wal Marts in Enterprise Zones, saying “We don’t collect business specific Canada Goose sale information.” Under the California Administrative Code vouchers granted in EZ zones are confidential, but the figures are accessible to the zone staff, the zone governing body, the California Franchise Tax Board, and the state Department of Housing. But here’s an example: An eligible Wal Mart worker making $12 an hour for 35 hours a week translates into a “hiring credit” worth roughly $11,000 half his salary in the first year. That’s $1.1 million per 100 qualified workers. The credit continues for 5 years at stepped down levels but the total tax break for Wal Marts in California EZs could be in the millions. canada goose discount uk

canada goose stockists uk For two decades, Wal Mart has been sucking down public revenues through such tax breaks, adding to the uk canada goose Golden State’s Wall of Debt, and claiming lucrative hiring credits that are uk canada goose outlet of dubious economic value. In 2011, Wal Mart had net cheap Canada Goose sales of $419 billion, and certainly did not need to rely on public welfare for any of its locations in California. According to one media source in 2009 Enterprise Zones canada goose factory sale received “nearly $500 million in tax breaks, benefiting companies like Wal Mart, which locate their distribution centers in economically distressed areas.” canada goose stockists uk

official canada goose outlet Jerry Brown’s threat to take away these corporate subsidies provoked the bureaucracy that depends on this welfare to create a new lobbying entity called Californians for Jobs and Safe Communities (CJSC), which was founded by the California Association of Enterprise Zones. This group hired former staffers from Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger’s canada goose clearance campaigns to canada goose uk shop serve as their PR consultants. official canada goose outlet

canada goose parka outlet uk California should learn from its own painful history. In February of 2005, the Institute on Canada Goose Online Taxation and Economic Policy released a report which showed that the corporate income tax in California, as a percentage of gross state product, had fallen by 34% between 1989 and 2003. The report warned that states should “stop providing foolish canadian goose jacket state corporate tax subsidies. When you find yourself in a hole, the first thing you need to do is stop digging. States need to stop giving away corporate taxes in the name of economic development. Chasing after businesses by fighting over who can give the largest tax concessions is a zero sum game.” canada goose parka outlet uk

canada goose outlet buffalo In that same year, Cathedral City, California watched helplessly as its ‘old’ Wal Mart closed, and a new super Wal Mart held a ribbon cutting in the neighboring community of Palm Springs. Cathedral City made a 10 year sales tax Canada Goose Jackets investment in Wal Mart, giving the retailer an escalating sales tax rebate that reached as high as $800,000 a year. Just when Wal Mart would have begun paying its full share of sales taxes back to the city, the corporation shuttered its store, pulled up stakes, and moved one town over, leaving Cathedral City with a big hole in its budget. “Wal Mart loves to tell you they’re a good corporate neighbor, they take care of the community; and that’s just wrong, they’re not,” Cathedral City’s former Mayor Pro buy canada goose jacket tem Greg Pettis told The Desert Sun newspaper. “They come into a buy canada goose jacket cheap community and (we) anticipate we’re going to make some long term money and in essence we reimburse them for the sales tax they generate. They haven’t done anything for this community.” canada goose outlet buffalo

canada goose outlet edmonton California can’t afford Enterprise Zone welfare, and companies like Wal Mart don’t need financial help from taxpayers. Very soon, the California Assembly will have to make a choice: between Wal Mart or a Wall of Debt. canada goose outlet edmonton

canada goose outlet winnipeg address Al Norman is the founder of Sprawl Busters which has helped local coalitions fight big box sprawl since 1993 canada goose outlet winnipeg address.

Leave a Reply